I got both the Brown and Maroon Brown pencils. Whilst I won't be repurchasing, these were great to use, and they definitely won't rub off: I got some on my bathroom floor and not even cleaning spray could get it off, I literally had to go in with a facial oil cleanser. On a separate occasion, I walked home in the heavy rain without an umbrella and they stuck around admirably. Saying that, it first of all has a bit of glitter in it - which doesn't seem to be mentioned. I'm trying to cut back on glittery products because of things like microplastics + just generally isn't what I'm going for. It's also not that smooth, Brown often got stuck on skin (maroon was much smoother), or the pigment was not consistent. Otherwise it was easy to work with and definitely one of the easier pencil liners out there.