Maybe it's because I've been alternating between this and the axis-y - New skin resolution mask, I've given this 4 out of 5 stars because I prefer the other one more and reach for it more often through the week. This is still a very good mask, however, and I still get great results from it; I just don't find it as cooling or as relaxing as the other mask. It has a very interesting soft and, almost fluffy (?) consistency to it. In the jar it kinda reminds me of baby food (haha) but doesn't drip or feel wet, and has a very faint tea fragrance which I really appreciate. It sits well on the skin and leaves it feeling clean and fortified. Despite the 4 stars, I would buy it again!